COMPARISON OF DIAGNOSTIC ACCURACY OF CHOKAI AND STONE SCORES TO DIAGNOSE URETERIC CALCULI

Authors

  • Shafeullah Ahadi Author
  • Atif Javed Author
  • Muhammad Farjad Author
  • Quratulain Badar Author
  • Muhammad Waqas Arshad Author
  • Muhammad Owais Ramzan Author
  • Azhar Ghayoor Yousaf Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.4238/qktym823

Keywords:

CHOKAI score, STONE score, ureteric calculi, CT-KUB, diagnostic accuracy, renal colic, Pakistan

Abstract

Objective: To compare the diagnostic accuracy of the CHOKAI and STONE scores for detecting ureteric calculi, using non-contrast CT-KUB as the reference standard, in a Pakistani emergency department setting. Methods: This cross-sectional study was conducted at the Department of Urology, Ziauddin Hospital, Karachi. A total of 231 adult patients (aged ≥18 years) presenting with acute renal colic were consecutively enrolled. CHOKAI and STONE scores were calculated for all participants, followed by non-contrast CT-KUB imaging. Diagnostic performance parameters including sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV), and area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) were calculated. Subgroup analyses were performed by stone size (<3 mm vs ≥3 mm) and BMI category (≤30 kg/m² vs >30 kg/m²). Results: Among 231 patients (median age= 38.0 years), non-contrast CT-KUB confirmed ureteric calculi in 170 (73.6%). At the pre-specified threshold of ≥10, the CHOKAI score showed higher sensitivity than the STONE score (82.9% vs 17.1%) but lower specificity (42.6% vs 90.2%). Overall diagnostic accuracy was superior for CHOKAI (72.3% vs 36.4%, p<0.001). The CHOKAI score achieved a significantly higher area under the receiver operating characteristic curve than the STONE score (AUC 0.691, 95% CI 0.612–0.769 vs 0.526, p<0.001). Both scores had low negative predictive value (CHOKAI 47.3%, STONE 28.1%). The application of a CHOKAI-based rule-out strategy would have resulted in 29 missed CT-confirmed calculi (52.7%), suggesting that neither CHOKAI nor STONE is sufficiently reliable to replace CT-KUB for exclusion of ureteric calculi. Conclusion: CHOKAI demonstrated significantly superior diagnostic discrimination compared with STONE for ureteric calculi in this South Asian population. However, its limited sensitivity indicates that neither score can safely replace CT-KUB for exclusion of calculi. CHOKAI may serve as a useful non-invasive adjunct for risk stratification and CT triage, particularly in resource-limited settings, pending prospective validation.

Downloads

Published

2026-09-06

Issue

Section

Articles